National Coverage Analysis (NCA) View Public Comments

Transcatheter Edge-to-Edge Repair for Tricuspid Valve Regurgitation (T-TEER)

Public Comments

Commenter Comment Information
Mixon, Tim Title: Physician
Organization: Baylor Scott & White Health
Date: 10/11/2024
Comment:
I am writing in support of the application for CMS coverage of tricuspid TEER therapy. For virtually all of my cardiology practice (21 years), we have rarely offered therapy for tricuspid regurgitation, despite abundant data showing a strong association between worsening TR, worsening RV size and function, and outcomes that all care about, such as mortality and heart failure (along with it's frequent requirement for hospitalization). TEER therapy now has a strong track record of safe and

More

Campbell, Camille Title: Nature's Medicine
Organization: The Naturel Group LLC. (Paths of Nature)
Date: 10/10/2024
Comment:

Drink lots licorice root and rasberry bulb test with rose rub your body down with arnica oils an vitamins D, B, and K and vapor rub which will cause circulation to move through the issue lite movements and patience with your little one an your self. Maybe every a baby asprini and orange juice with beets juice mix in sanpellgrino or goood tasting $0.99 sparkling water like ICE or Clear Choice etc. with a few slices of citirus fruit light salads pre made from Walmart and Target with meats

More

Pressman, Gregg Title: Director of Academics - Cardiology
Organization: Jefferson Einstein Hospital, Thomas Jefferson University
Date: 10/09/2024
Comment:
The recent development of structural interventions for treatment of valvular heart disease is one of the most significant advances in Medicine in the last 100 years. We finally can treat patients who otherwise often die of heart failure. The improvements in general health and cardiac outcomes provided by mitral TEER are impressive. Tricuspid TEER has similar potential for patients suffering from severe or greater tricuspid regurgitation. I heartily support Medicare coverage for this procedure

More

Cubeddu, Robert Title: Structural Cardiologist
Organization: NCH
Date: 10/09/2024
Comment:

I am significantly in favor and strongly advocate for CMS approval for tricuspid valve TEER. This procedure is safe and associated with significant reduction in TR severity. Having been involved in the care of these patients and completed over 30 tricuspid TEER procedures I have been a direct witness of the immediate and mid-term impact on patient's symptoms, quality of life and heart failure class. It is quite remarkable in the appropriate clinical and anatomical setting.

More

Goessl, Mario Date: 10/09/2024
Comment:
In expert hands and after thorough efforts of optimized medical therapy and continued GDMT and OMT after the T-TEER procedure, TriClip has shown to improve quality of life in patients who don't have other alternatives. In an attempt to achieve similar value for the patients, it appears critical to ask for the same thoroughness and expertise going forward. This is not a popular topic but in order to provide best value for these patients, guardrails like documented optimization of medical

More

Ramee, Stephen Title: Professor of Clinical Medicine, LSUHSC New Orleans
Date: 10/09/2024
Comment:
I'm a Board Certified Cardiologist and practitioner. I treat patients with valvular heart disease on a daily basis. I have participated in the T-TEER FDA trials.
Tricuspid Regurgitation is a condition with limited surgical availability because the patients often have liver failure from passive congestion which makes them surgically inoperable. Most if not all of these patients with severe TR which is not adequately managed medically, will have an improved clinical outcome with

More

Sharma, Rahul Title: MD, Interventional Cardiology and Strucutral Heart
Organization: Cardiac Solutions
Date: 10/09/2024
Comment:
As an operator of transcatheter edge to edge repair for Tricuspid Regurgitation, I can personally attest to the dramatic symptom and quality of life improvement experienced by my patients. The TriClip device has given this undertreated severe TR patients an opportunity to live and breath again! This therapy should be made easily accessible and widely available at appropriate medical centers so that patients can be treated in the communities in which they live and treated by experts who can

More

Moossavi, Shahab Title: Interventional Cardiologist
Date: 10/07/2024
Comment:
I agree with coverage based on the guidelines for symptomatic patients with moderate to severe TR.
Any hospital with Heart team and already offering TEER for mitral valve should be covered for TEER for TR.
Hall, Cam Organization: RRH
Date: 10/07/2024
Comment:
While still in its infancy, I have not seen the clinical benefits of TVR in any form to have a significant clinical impact on outcomes.
If there is a benefit, it will likely be small. Offset by the cost of the therapy, unclear if this is going to survive in value based care system.